High Court Rules Owners Liable For Business Rates

Posted on 25 November, 2014 by Cliff Goodwin

Property owners are legally responsible for business rates owed by a tenant who has ceased trading, the High Court has ruled.

signing a lease with pen and keys

The precedent came with the court’s rejection of an appeal by Schroders Exempt Property Unit Trust (SEPUT) that it could not be held liable for rates owed to Birmingham City Council once a tenant goes into liquidation and moves out. A previous judgment ruled that the company must pay a £600,000 business rates bill.

“Whilst this decision is bad news for many landlords, at least it provides useful clarification as to who is responsible for business rates following disclaimer of a lease,” commented Chris Billson, a director of commercial agents Prop-Search.

In the SEPUT case, a lease was granted to a tenant who then assigned the lease and provided an Authorised Guarantee Agreement (AGA), guaranteeing the assignee’s obligations under the lease. When the assignee was liquidated, and moved out of the property, the lease was disclaimed.

Whilst the landlord continued to recover rent from the original tenant — in line with the guarantee agreement — the local authority demanded payment of the business rates from the landlord for the period after the disclaimer. The city council was ultimately granted a liability order.

SEPUT appealed, claiming that it was not entitled to possession of the property since it had not forfeited the lease. It also argued the guarantor could potentially claim an overriding lease under the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, which would entitle the guarantor to possession.

The High Court appeal judges disagreed, however, and ruled that the true consequence of disclaimer was that the lease ceased to exist and that SEPUT became entitled to immediate possession.

The guarantor remained liable to make good the tenant’s defaults, not because the lease subsisted, the court said, but because it was contractually liable to do so. The court therefore concluded that SEPUT, as landlord, was liable for payment of the business rates in full.

“Unfortunately, there is logic in the landlord being directly liable to pay the business rates as the lease is ultimately at an end and the landlord entitled to possession,” added Billson. “The guarantor does not somehow step into the shoes of the assignee, save in respect of possession of the property.”

Landlords and property owners are not totally powerless, he stressed. “It would be expected that any original tenant providing an AGA or any other guarantee for a tenant in occupation would be liable for all liabilities that fall due pursuant to the lease,” explained the Prop-Search executive.

In the event of default — such as non-payment of rates — the guarantor is responsible for this. “As a result, whilst the local authority need only pursue the landlord following the disclaimer, the landlord may well have a remedy against another party in any event to off-set the liability to the local authority,” concluded Billson.




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Recent Posts

Interest Rates Impact on Commercial Property

Commercial Property Investment Outlook for 2023

The best places to stay on the Riviera

The latest property data has identified Newquay as the fastest property seller’s market in the UK

Investing in your garden can increase your property’s value

French Riviera temping high-end homebuyers

How can the ownership rights of my commercial property impact a business sale?

Should I incorporate virtual property viewings permanently?

Investment expected to increase across Asia-Pacific in 2021

UK property industry slows as the conclusion of tax break looms

BNP Paribas cautioned investors on Friday as debt-trading bonanza that increased its earnings this past year

Over 300,000 property purchases fell through in 2020 – we show the most frequent motives and the best way to get your house sale back on track

House Prices in the Capital Surpass £500,000

Optimism from the Bank of England’s chief economist

The most expensive commercial properties.

Businesses operating from shared premises will miss out on grants