There is no Office Shortage in London Smithfield Inquiry hears

Posted on 24 February, 2014 by Neil Bird

The controversial redevelopment of London’s Smithfield Market is not warranted by a shortage of office space in the capital, a public inquiry has been told.

There-is-no-Office-Shortage-in-London-Smithfield-Inquiry-hears

The multi-million pound redevelopment of the Victorian market hall has divided opinion, both in the architectural profession and among heritage groups.

On one side of the argument are those who say that the proposed office and retail scheme will breathe new life into the neglected property. On the other, opponents claim that it will rip the heart out of one of the finest buildings of its type in Europe.

Last week the public inquiry into the scheme heard from a commercial property expert giving evidence for the developer Henderson Global Investors. Andrew Tyler, of Knight Frank, said that a rival plan, which would retain more of the building’s original fabric, was unviable on the grounds that it lacked detail and had not been properly costed.

Now, the inquiry has heard that a lack of office space cannot be used to justify implementing the plans as they stand,

Speaking on behalf of the Victorian Society and Save Britain’s Heritage, former town planner Alec Forshaw told the inquiry that there were a number of office development schemes in the pipeline which would satisfy demand.

“There may be a housing crisis in London but there isn’t an office crisis,” he said.

Under cross examination from the Corporation of London’s barrister Neil Cameron, Forshaw conceded that he was not an “office letting professional” and that he accepted that any use of the building was better than none.

But he insisted that the “restoration” of the property should not be considered to be “in the public benefit” if the scheme has to be weighed up against the harm it may cause.

Closing submissions from both sides are due to be heard on Friday.




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Recent Posts

Interest Rates Impact on Commercial Property

Commercial Property Investment Outlook for 2023

The best places to stay on the Riviera

The latest property data has identified Newquay as the fastest property seller’s market in the UK

Investing in your garden can increase your property’s value

French Riviera temping high-end homebuyers

How can the ownership rights of my commercial property impact a business sale?

Should I incorporate virtual property viewings permanently?

Investment expected to increase across Asia-Pacific in 2021

UK property industry slows as the conclusion of tax break looms

BNP Paribas cautioned investors on Friday as debt-trading bonanza that increased its earnings this past year

Over 300,000 property purchases fell through in 2020 – we show the most frequent motives and the best way to get your house sale back on track

House Prices in the Capital Surpass £500,000

Optimism from the Bank of England’s chief economist

The most expensive commercial properties.

Businesses operating from shared premises will miss out on grants